PARENTING: Sibling Rivalry
Having one child makes you a parent, having two makes you a referee
By Dr. Vivek Sharma
![]() |
Dr. Vivek Sharma |
Jennifer Connelly's (Hollywood actress) five year old son Kai was ambivalent about the arrival of sibling in 2003. After hearing that the child was another boy (rather than the hoped for girl), he stormed out of the hospital premises in a huff. Sometime later, Connelly and her family found themselves discussing possible names for their newest member, how about jack? or James? "I have an idea"; Kai interjected. "How about punch bag?"
(Source: Late night with Connon O' Brien Sept., 2003)
Such feelings of jealousy and rivalry exist in everyone in childhood. They become a problem when they interfere with adjustment to work or sleep or are reflected in insidious behaviour. In a child such feelings if intense, can destroy his whole outlook to life.
Understanding Sibling Relationship
Sibling relationships typically, last longer than other family relationships and are often characterized by higher levels of interactivity, shared experiences and support. This is especially true when there is nearness in age and when there is a good degree of involvement in each other's lives; this automatically indicates the strong influence that sibling bonds have on a child's life. So much so that traumatic events like parental divorce, or even the loss of a parent, may make sibling bonds even more crucial. For example, in the case of a divorce between the parents, the sibling bond will play an important role even when weaker relationships with other family members may suffer, and the children grow closer to each other.
The positive impact of an older sibling who takes on the mantle of a role model for the younger ones cannot be denied. If they are a little older, they automatically assume a nurturing or care-taking role which continues well into adulthood. This is especially with today's busy world where both parents are out at work, and the elder one is often given the responsibility of 'looking after' the younger sibling.
Judy Dunn (a leading expert on sibling relationship) in 2007 described three important characteristics of sibling relationships –
• Emotional quality of the relationship: Both intensive positive and negative emotions are often expressed by siblings toward each other. Many children and adolescents have mixed feelings toward their siblings.
• Familiarity and intimacy of the relationship: Siblings typically prove each other very well, and this intimacy suggests that they can either provide support or tease and undermine each other, depending on the situation.
• Variation and Sibling relationship: Some siblings describe their relationship more positively than others. Thus, there is considerable variation in sibling relationships.
Many siblings have mixed feelings about each other, but some children and adolescents mainly describe their siblings in warm, affectionate ways, whereas others primarily talk about how irritating a mean sibling is.
Sibling Rivalry
Speak roughly to your little boy/and beat him when he sneezes; / he only does it to annoy, / because he knows it teases. (Caroll, Lewis)
In a house with more than one kid, there are bound to be some problems, younger kids sometimes feel like the older kids get to do whatever they want. Older brother and sisters think that the baby of the family gets more attention. These are typical problems found throughout the ages everywhere in the world.
When brother and sisters don't get along, it's called sibling rivalry. A sibling is a brother or sister and rivalry means competition.
It is a type of competition or animosity among brother and sisters, blood related or not. For example there is an Arabic saying: "I against my brother, my brother and I against my cousins; I, my brother, and my cousin against the stranger."
Sibling rivalry usually starts right after or before arrival of the second child, the older child can become aggressive, "act out", or regress (act more like a baby).
Sigmund Freud saw the sibling relationship as an extension of the Oedipus complex, where brothers were in competition for their mothers' attention and sisters for their fathers'.
How Sibling Rivalry Presents
Sibling Rivalry is manifested in various, sometimes subtle ways. Some children are openly hostile to their new siblings, while others are more diffident about expressing their negative feelings. Some older siblings give the baby a good pinch or try to hurt the new born while your back is turned. Another child may seem to be responding favourably to the new entrant in the family until she politely queries when the baby is being taken back to the hospital. Some older siblings show no animosity to the new born at all preferring instead to turn their anger on their mothers. Some children go to another extreme attempting to suppress their jealousy. They develop a kind of obsession with the new born. The new baby becomes a point of reference for everything that they see or do. This is neither natural, nor healthy.
Some Famous sibling rivalry instances
- Cane and Abel in Bible
- Joseph and his brother in Bible
- Goneril, Regan, and Cordelia; Edmund and Edgar in King Lear (Shakespeare)
- Elinor and Marianne Dashwood in Sense and Sensibility (Jane Austen)
- Sonny, Fredo and Michael Corleone in the film The Godfather
- May and Mox In Manga Pokemon
- In real life tennis players Venus and Serena Williams
Circumstances Causing Sibling Rivalry
• A child’s personality can also have an effect on how much sibling rivalry will occur in a home. Some kids seem to naturally accept changes, while others may be naturally competitive and exhibit this nature long before a sibling enters a home.
• Positioning in the family – for example, the oldest child may be burdened with responsibility for younger cildren. The younger child spends his life trying to catch up with an older sibling.
• When one sibling is handicapped – Quite different considerations must come into play when there is a handicapped child in the family, especially if it is a youngster who requires a lot of extra services both in and out of the home. In this case non-handicapped siblings can be resentful of the time spent on their brother or sister. They sense the parents’ preoccupation. They feel that often they are receiving only surface attention, that the parents are not really alert to their needs.
• Sex, for instance a son may hate his sister because his father seems gentle with her. On the other hand, a daughter may wish she could go on to hunting trip with her father and brothers.
• Age – a five and an eight year old child can play the same game together but when they become ten and thirteen, they will probably be poles apart.
• When one sibling is gifted – different people, gifted children, have abilities and talents in different areas.
• Stress in the parents and childrens' lives can create more conflict and Sibling Rivalry.
• Encouraging competition, especially where winning is the object, can provoke severe sibling rivalry.
• The most important factor, is parental attitude. Parents have been taught that they may be impartial but this can be extremely difficult.
How Parents can Help?
• Avoid labeling and comparing - Don't make comparisons. Instead of comparisons, each child in the family should be given his own goals and levels of expectations that relate only to him.
• Shield younger children (siblings) from no win situations. Younger children often want to compare with older siblings, which can be very disappointing when they keep losing.
• Don't dismiss or suppress your children's resentment and angry feelings. The resentment is the time to sit down, acknowledge the changes and talk it out thoroughly.
• Use humor – Just as in any conflict, humor can dispel tension that builds with disputes.
• Try to avoid situations that promote guilt in siblings. The guilt that follows doing something mean is a lot worse than the guilt of merely feeling mean. So parental intervention must be quick and decisive.
• When possible, let brothers and sisters settle their own differences. Sounds good but it can be terribly unfair in practice. Parents have to judge when it is time to step in and mediate, especially in a contest of unequals in terms of strength and eloquence.
• Remove the source of the conflict and distraction - If a particular item seems to be cause of the conflict, remove it for a period of time.
• Help children understand that their actions bring consequences – consequences are an alternative to punishment but don't confuse consequences with bribing.
• Set a good example in your children - Your children are watching how you handle disagreements and arguments with your spouse and your friends and extended family. They look to your example for how to work out their own problems.
Siblings can create certain stresses but if they are overcome successfully, that will serve them well later in life.
Best of all as they watch you handle sibling rivalry with equanimity and fairness, they will be gaining knowledge; that will be valuable when they, too, become parents.
[Dr. Vivek Sharma is a Consultant Paediatrician in Rungta Hospital, Jaipur. His works can be seen on his website SlowLearner.co.in. He can be contacted at drvivek_sharma@rediffmail.com or on 09829062347, 0141-2752347]