Published On:26 August 2013
Posted by Indian Muslim Observer

Why Muslims don’t win Nobel Prizes

While the West invested in innovation, Muslims did not

By Fakir S. Ayazuddin

“All the world’s Muslims have fewer Nobel Prizes than Trinity College, Cambridge. They did great things in the Middle Ages, though”.

When I read this headline from an article by Richard Dawkins, I realised that he was at his Islam bashing best. I was at first offended, thinking that perhaps this was yet another attempt at denigrating Islam. However when considered that it is a fact that cannot be denied, then perhaps one should look deeper into the cause of such a lapse in the educational achievements between the Islamic culture versus the West.

The last bit was rather patronising, but unfortunately factual.

Over the last millennia the Muslims were way ahead of the west in their culture, and education. And stayed ahead till the renaissance, when art and science took root, in Europe. Till that time the West were hunter gatherers too busy in just surviving. After the Renaissance, the Europeans picked up the pace, and their interest and investment in education grew.

Then the invention of the steam engine by James Watt and then Stephenson in 1830 was used by the coal industry, and by steamers. This source of power was used in industry, textiles was the first to go from spinning wool by hand to spinning machines, designed and operated by engineers in the midlands. There was a close link between the inventors and the engineers —- education. The quantum leap was after steam power was applied to Industry, and—as they say, the rest is history. The discovery of oil, made the engine mobile, and the automobile was on its way. Aeroplanes were not far behind, in fact aircraft and automobiles were invented at the same time. After the induction of oil as the supply of power, and the mobility of oil as a power source.

In these years the west kept increasing their investment in education, adding to their inventions. Indeed Alfred Nobel invented dynamite and went on to make his fortune, and then created his Nobel Prize to benefit inventors, and thinkers. This is an example of the benefits of money being passed on to deserving recipients. There is no comparable example in the Muslim world.

In the same period, the Ottoman Empire built many beautiful mosques, but no schools of higher learning. The Muslims were kept at their primitive level of education, and even the great libraries of Baghdad were routinely destroyed. The value of education that the Holy Prophet had prescribed was ignored and wantonly destroyed. The west continued on its march of progress while the Muslims carried on in their pursuit of pleasure, spending their amassed wealth in frivolous and wanton excesses.

In the 19th century, with the advent of the automobile and aeroplanes, the pace of growth was exponential, with Nobel prizes a yearly addition acknowledging invention and innovation.

The two World Wars changed the players, catapulting the Americans and Russians to the front with the Cold War fuelling a cutthroat competition. While the huge amounts of oil money that came the Arab way was mostly frittered away into the pursuit of physical comforts and carnal pleasures, not much was put into education. In fact a lot of money was invested in the colleges of the US like Harvard and MIT which have huge endowments from the Arab oil wealth.

Now, of course just the invention and spread of the internet has created probably the biggest leap in man’s knowledge – more than all the years preceding it. It is education alone that can expand the human horizon, into the huge unknown, creating knowledge for the coming generations. The internet has also freed mankind from all religious constraints.

(Courtesy: Pakistan Today)

About the Author

Posted by Indian Muslim Observer on August 26, 2013. Filed under , , , , . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. Feel free to leave a response

By Indian Muslim Observer on August 26, 2013. Filed under , , , , . Follow any responses to the RSS 2.0. Leave a response

2 comments for "Why Muslims don’t win Nobel Prizes"

  1. It is like asking why only a few westerners got Faisal Awards? Nobel prizes are basically distributed among Jews and Western scientists and only few scholars and scientists from other countries receive them. There is a lot of politics behind it. The example is that of China, India and Russia which respectively have 11, 8 and 26 Nobel laureates. China and India have comparable populations with the Muslim world and had fetched almost the same number of Nobel awards. If Obama gets Nobel for peace and spread wars in different countries then what value the prize carry for people. Muslims should not be disheartened by such demoralizing attempts. But, they needs to think how their forefathers led the two millenniums of development, at that time Europe was in the dark age?

  2. Cent Percent Right. Instead of thinking and striving for Nobel Prize. People must lift themselves (progress and development), but within the parameters of Quran, Hadith and Shirah.

Leave a reply

Donate to Sustain IMO

IMO Search

IMO Visitors